Naughty James

[Mucky1978]

James Clare up for a disciplinary for punch.

[yorky]

i think who ever upset him should apologise

[Tigers1926]

He should get off for good behaviour or mistaken identity, because I cannot ever remember Jimmy throwing a punch in anger, EVER!

[bane73]

What happened for him to throw a punch?

[Tigers1926]

No idea to be honest, infact I didn't realise he'd gone off..

[cvtiger]

Always been a lover not a fighter…

[mart0042]

I've seen the incident and didn't see a punch connect. Anything more than sin bin sufficient means we are in for another bad year of bad rfl decisions. If that's a grade D , Sinfields headbutt on Luke dorn was attempt murder and he got 2 matches and sent off.

[JIN JER]

This, I’ve seen the “punch” and it’s ridiculous that he’s even been accused of punching

[Gomersal Tiger]

If the doomsters on this website could have their way, a 12 month ban would be punishment.

[stevieblunder]

Has he been banned?

No news on Disciplinary Panel sitting since last weekend.

[the changeling]

The RFL will punish us and let him off with a small fine

[yellow_t-shirt]

When I see 3-5 games ban it's laughable! I assume previous record doesn't count for anything these days?! I don't know James personally but what I see of him in matches it's not in his nature.

[Fumper27]

When I see 3-5 games ban it's laughable! I assume previous record doesn't count for anything these days?! I don't know James personally but what I see of him in matches it's not in his nature.

Previous record counted for Tommy Makinson when he got sent off against us last season.

[jackknife]

Tbh if James Clare got 5match ban it wouldn't affect us very much, i doubt he'll be anywhere near the starting 17 unless we continue with the injury bad luck we have had last few years.

[Tigers1926]

Whether JC gets a 5 match ban or not, that's not the point. I cannot ever recall him being up infront o the disciplinary panel, so surely previous good behaviour does come into the equation as Fumper pointed out with Tommy Makinson. Or is it going to further mine and many other Cas fans view that the rfl disciplinary dept is shocking and not fit for purpose and basically corrupt

[mart0042]

Whether JC gets a 5 match ban or not, that's not the point. I cannot ever recall him being up infront o the disciplinary panel, so surely previous good behaviour does come into the equation as Fumper pointed out with Tommy Makinson. Or is it going to further mine and many other Cas fans view that the rfl disciplinary dept is shocking and not fit for purpose and basically corrupt

The disciplinary is ineffective, corrupt and are as bad as the ref on the field, who is not helped by the touchies. IMHO.

The "right" teams get the calls. I'll take you back to Jamie peacock kneeling on top of a player and punching him twice in the face where he couldn't defend himself. No ban, provocation and excellent disciplinary record the reasoning. There are so more but it's just pointless.

[old cas lass]

As this been sorted yet.

[mart0042]

Still only shows as a charge on the website. It normally convenes the following week. I would expect this week, especially as the championship clubs start their League this weekend.

[mart0042]

https://www.rugby-league.com/article/36 ... C-tribunal

I just don't believe it! (Think Victor Meldrew ) 3 matches for that. There's gonna be some squads short this season. The pie eaters won't be able to put a team together after round 1.

[stevieblunder]

Very lenient.

Should have been a lot more.!!!

Violent aggressive player .

People like him shouldn't be allowed on a rugby field.

This is the Hannibal Lector thread.???

If not my apologies.