Exactly! You can’t compare. These lads are putting their bodies on the line in a tough, professional sport. I think 20k starting for a 19/20 year old is fair to be honest.Let’s talk sense wrote: ↑07 Oct 2019, 22:08 I had to come in at this point. Message to Nottingham Tiger. Do me a favour please! Don’t compare the job of an aspiring rugby player with that of a four year obtaining pen pusher. These guys are getting smashed about. Maybe not 20-25k as a starting point but definitely 15-18.
Jamie Ellis
-
- League One Player
- Posts: 2986
- Joined: 21 Dec 2014, 00:40
- Contact:
Re: Jamie Ellis
-
- Championship Player
- Posts: 5272
- Joined: 11 Jul 2006, 16:17
- Contact:
Re: Jamie Ellis
Damn those pesky pen-pushers who educate our children, run our hospitals, seek cures for illnesses, prosecute criminals and protect the vulnerable in society.Let’s talk sense wrote: ↑07 Oct 2019, 22:08 I had to come in at this point. Message to Nottingham Tiger. Do me a favour please! Don’t compare the job of an aspiring rugby player with that of a four year obtaining pen pusher. These guys are getting smashed about. Maybe not 20-25k as a starting point but definitely 15-18.
I’m afraid anyone can do “getting smashed about” and it’s pretty low-level in terms of an employment skill.
-
- Academy Player
- Posts: 137
- Joined: 26 Jul 2019, 23:41
- Contact:
Re: Jamie Ellis
And everyone who possesses a degree falls into all those categories! Oh deary me. I give in.nottinghamtiger wrote: ↑07 Oct 2019, 22:28Damn those pesky pen-pushers who educate our children, run our hospitals, seek cures for illnesses, prosecute criminals and protect the vulnerable in society.Let’s talk sense wrote: ↑07 Oct 2019, 22:08 I had to come in at this point. Message to Nottingham Tiger. Do me a favour please! Don’t compare the job of an aspiring rugby player with that of a four year obtaining pen pusher. These guys are getting smashed about. Maybe not 20-25k as a starting point but definitely 15-18.
I’m afraid anyone can do “getting smashed about” and it’s pretty low-level in terms of an employment skill.
-
- Championship Player
- Posts: 5272
- Joined: 11 Jul 2006, 16:17
- Contact:
Re: Jamie Ellis
Well obviously not, but likewise it’s worth remembering that everyone who does those jobs do tend to have degrees. To label the likes of teachers, nurses, medical researchers, social workers etc as “pen pushers” is rather narrow-minded.Let’s talk sense wrote: ↑07 Oct 2019, 22:49And everyone who possesses a degree falls into all those categories! Oh deary me. I give in.nottinghamtiger wrote: ↑07 Oct 2019, 22:28Damn those pesky pen-pushers who educate our children, run our hospitals, seek cures for illnesses, prosecute criminals and protect the vulnerable in society.Let’s talk sense wrote: ↑07 Oct 2019, 22:08 I had to come in at this point. Message to Nottingham Tiger. Do me a favour please! Don’t compare the job of an aspiring rugby player with that of a four year obtaining pen pusher. These guys are getting smashed about. Maybe not 20-25k as a starting point but definitely 15-18.
I’m afraid anyone can do “getting smashed about” and it’s pretty low-level in terms of an employment skill.
The thing is, the rationale for paying a 20k+ salary to someone simply because they get “smashed about” just doesn’t seem equitable.
Re: Jamie Ellis
I thought this was supposed to e a thread about Jamie Ellis, yet we have 2 pages on the subject of juniors playing rugby league and how much they are worth. Another thread derailed, what a surprise.
Re: Jamie Ellis
Give it a rest with the detailing... yes it's a Jamie Ellis thread but as part of that its evolved into other areas. What do people want a new topic every time someone mentions something slightly off topic. FFS
Re: Jamie Ellis
Here here fords. Absolutely ridiculous
Audacter Et Sincere
-
- League One Player
- Posts: 4975
- Joined: 06 Jul 2006, 09:17
- Contact:
Re: Jamie Ellis
Wow do you really believe anyone can do getting bashed about, I’d say rugby players are a pretty broad church when it comes to education many will have missed out on university to peruse a sporting dream. To assume they are all thick and not worthy of the “important jobs” in life is just damn rude.nottinghamtiger wrote: ↑07 Oct 2019, 22:28Damn those pesky pen-pushers who educate our children, run our hospitals, seek cures for illnesses, prosecute criminals and protect the vulnerable in society.Let’s talk sense wrote: ↑07 Oct 2019, 22:08 I had to come in at this point. Message to Nottingham Tiger. Do me a favour please! Don’t compare the job of an aspiring rugby player with that of a four year obtaining pen pusher. These guys are getting smashed about. Maybe not 20-25k as a starting point but definitely 15-18.
I’m afraid anyone can do “getting smashed about” and it’s pretty low-level in terms of an employment skill.
If I was employing a lad to do any job I’d take a lad that as shown professionalism,dedication and a work ethic over some of the lay about students every time.
-
- Championship Player
- Posts: 5272
- Joined: 11 Jul 2006, 16:17
- Contact:
Re: Jamie Ellis
I actually said very few of those things, if any.braytontiger wrote: ↑08 Oct 2019, 09:48Wow do you really believe anyone can do getting bashed about, I’d say rugby players are a pretty broad church when it comes to education many will have missed out on university to peruse a sporting dream. To assume they are all thick and not worthy of the “important jobs” in life is just damn rude.nottinghamtiger wrote: ↑07 Oct 2019, 22:28Damn those pesky pen-pushers who educate our children, run our hospitals, seek cures for illnesses, prosecute criminals and protect the vulnerable in society.Let’s talk sense wrote: ↑07 Oct 2019, 22:08 I had to come in at this point. Message to Nottingham Tiger. Do me a favour please! Don’t compare the job of an aspiring rugby player with that of a four year obtaining pen pusher. These guys are getting smashed about. Maybe not 20-25k as a starting point but definitely 15-18.
I’m afraid anyone can do “getting smashed about” and it’s pretty low-level in terms of an employment skill.
If I was employing a lad to do any job I’d take a lad that as shown professionalism,dedication and a work ethic over some of the lay about students every time.
Someone argued that wages such be high simply because they get “smashed about”. All I said was that this in itself isn’t a reason to pay high wages,
There are some very astute and intelligent RL players, no doubt. Some will certainly have compromised on getting qualifications to play the game, or at least delayed getting them until their RL career comes to an end. I don’t think you’ll find anywhere where I’ve said that all RL players are thick and not worthy of important jobs. Many RL players do indeed go into teaching, particularly within secondary school PE departments.
I guess whether or not to employ someone purely depends on the actual job they want to do and for some jobs certain qualifications are required, but (as you say) almost all jobs involve professionalism, dedication and work ethic. But that wasn’t the point I was making - I was making the point that we shouldn’t be paying teenagers 20k+ a year, just because the job is a physical one.
Re: Jamie Ellis
With you...braytontiger wrote: ↑08 Oct 2019, 09:48Wow do you really believe anyone can do getting bashed about, I’d say rugby players are a pretty broad church when it comes to education many will have missed out on university to peruse a sporting dream. To assume they are all thick and not worthy of the “important jobs” in life is just damn rude.nottinghamtiger wrote: ↑07 Oct 2019, 22:28Damn those pesky pen-pushers who educate our children, run our hospitals, seek cures for illnesses, prosecute criminals and protect the vulnerable in society.Let’s talk sense wrote: ↑07 Oct 2019, 22:08 I had to come in at this point. Message to Nottingham Tiger. Do me a favour please! Don’t compare the job of an aspiring rugby player with that of a four year obtaining pen pusher. These guys are getting smashed about. Maybe not 20-25k as a starting point but definitely 15-18.
I’m afraid anyone can do “getting smashed about” and it’s pretty low-level in terms of an employment skill.
If I was employing a lad to do any job I’d take a lad that as shown professionalism,dedication and a work ethic over some of the lay about students every time.
Audacter Et Sincere
Re: Jamie Ellis
Hallelujah..Casmania wrote: A strong academy is the clubs future. Cas are lucky we are surrounded by schools and amateur clubs playing rugby league. You would have thought the club should be able to retain the best players and not see them leave to join fellow rivals
Totally this quote.
Why on God’s green Earth we don’t excel in this area is beyond me.
The big clubs spend big money on big players, let’s get back to really cleaning up junior talent. It’s here Wells could add value, if he told us he was revisiting junior recruitment...
Audacter Et Sincere
-
- League One Player
- Posts: 3597
- Joined: 10 Jan 2018, 15:27
- Contact:
Re: Jamie Ellis
Cas High is the most prestigious school in the country for Rugby League, both boys and girls, that is a fact! we need to tap in to this for the future.Mysterio wrote: ↑08 Oct 2019, 10:30Hallelujah..Casmania wrote: A strong academy is the clubs future. Cas are lucky we are surrounded by schools and amateur clubs playing rugby league. You would have thought the club should be able to retain the best players and not see them leave to join fellow rivals
Totally this quote.
Why on God’s green Earth we don’t excel in this area is beyond me.
The big clubs spend big money on big players, let’s get back to really cleaning up junior talent. It’s here Wells could add value, if he told us he was revisiting junior recruitment...
Re: Jamie Ellis
I’m a pen pusher on 40k a year.
Wouldn’t get out of bed for 25k.
Wouldn’t get out of bed for 25k.
Re: Jamie Ellis
Good comments , we have the opportunity with the talent in this area to make this the way forwardheritage1926 wrote: ↑08 Oct 2019, 10:37Cas High is the most prestigious school in the country for Rugby League, both boys and girls, that is a fact! we need to tap in to this for the future.Mysterio wrote: ↑08 Oct 2019, 10:30Hallelujah..Casmania wrote: A strong academy is the clubs future. Cas are lucky we are surrounded by schools and amateur clubs playing rugby league. You would have thought the club should be able to retain the best players and not see them leave to join fellow rivals
Totally this quote.
Why on God’s green Earth we don’t excel in this area is beyond me.
The big clubs spend big money on big players, let’s get back to really cleaning up junior talent. It’s here Wells could add value, if he told us he was revisiting junior recruitment...
Wells said it was the way forward also so let's hope we don't waste the chance
The measure of who we are is what we do with what we have
Vince Lombardi
Vince Lombardi
Re: Jamie Ellis
We should have a very close contact with Cas high and Airedale high, some of the players coming out of those schools are the players of the future. Has for Jamie Ellis, I take my hat off to him, Anyone to make the grade at top level in this sport are very good players. We missed Gale and Ellis all season, and especially goal kicking, we dropped at least eight point due to not having either one on the field
- Flat Capper
- Grand Final Winner
- Posts: 15173
- Joined: 06 Jul 2006, 00:10
- Location: Where ever I lay my fat
- Contact:
- westyorkylad
- Academy Player
- Posts: 331
- Joined: 20 Dec 2006, 13:23
- Contact:
Re: Jamie Ellis
Whilst the idea of paying youngsters at 18 £20 to £25k a year to sign a contract that may or may not see them play first team RL is certainly a very noble one, ultimately what they are offered will be determined by market forces, i.e. what are your competition paying (what is the going rate) and what can you afford.
The success rate of getting youngsters through the academy system and into a first team shirt is extremely low, I would suggest 1 to 2% when you remember that there is a new crop coming in each and every season.
There is a lot of work for very little reward to get a shot at making it as a first team player, and it has been this way for a number of years. This is not something new.
The success rate of getting youngsters through the academy system and into a first team shirt is extremely low, I would suggest 1 to 2% when you remember that there is a new crop coming in each and every season.
There is a lot of work for very little reward to get a shot at making it as a first team player, and it has been this way for a number of years. This is not something new.
Re: Jamie Ellis
Castleford were at one time renowned for bringing players into the game through the academy system.
The last player to truly make it was Daryl Clark.
We are now being left behind by Leeds, Wigan, Saints, Warrington and to some degree Huddersfield and Wakefield.
The last player to truly make it was Daryl Clark.
We are now being left behind by Leeds, Wigan, Saints, Warrington and to some degree Huddersfield and Wakefield.
MY CLUB. MY CAS
-
- League One Player
- Posts: 2811
- Joined: 05 Jul 2006, 18:35
- Twitter: @nathastbury
- Location: Greystones, County Wicklow
- Contact:
Re: Jamie Ellis
You could probably add widnes and London to that list too
Castleford tigers Irish supporters branch
-
Verified
- Grand Final Winner
- Posts: 15893
- Joined: 31 Jan 2009, 03:55
- Contact:
Re: Jamie Ellis
Bringing through talent isn't and shouldn't just be a numbers game. They have to be good enough and be able to challenge with the best.
Warrington aren't producers of talent, they are buyers of it from other clubs. The few they have brought through (King, Patton, Currie, Philbin) haven't really fulfilled potential yet or hit heady heights.
Huddersfield are bringing young players through but whether they're any good is a different matter. The fact that they scrapped for their lives suggests they're either not that good, or that they have thrown too many in at once and not allowed them development time.
You could say the same about Wakefield regarding us. Who was the last Super League talent they brought through? Tom Johnstone, which was back in 2014 I think, but before that it's probably someone like Gareth Ellis. The rest haven't amounted to much (Annakin, Ferguson etc all gone on to be released or moved on).
Wigan and Saints are by far the best and that's because they pay the most and recruit a huge number then discard them at a later stage. A quick look at their U16s squad shows them as having 39 players - 39!! Leeds were good but haven't brought through many recently of a good standard. The rest of SL clubs are lightyears behind.
If we want to recruit the best young players the money has to come from elsewhere when we're on a budget. Would we be prepared to reduce our first team budget for young kids?
Warrington aren't producers of talent, they are buyers of it from other clubs. The few they have brought through (King, Patton, Currie, Philbin) haven't really fulfilled potential yet or hit heady heights.
Huddersfield are bringing young players through but whether they're any good is a different matter. The fact that they scrapped for their lives suggests they're either not that good, or that they have thrown too many in at once and not allowed them development time.
You could say the same about Wakefield regarding us. Who was the last Super League talent they brought through? Tom Johnstone, which was back in 2014 I think, but before that it's probably someone like Gareth Ellis. The rest haven't amounted to much (Annakin, Ferguson etc all gone on to be released or moved on).
Wigan and Saints are by far the best and that's because they pay the most and recruit a huge number then discard them at a later stage. A quick look at their U16s squad shows them as having 39 players - 39!! Leeds were good but haven't brought through many recently of a good standard. The rest of SL clubs are lightyears behind.
If we want to recruit the best young players the money has to come from elsewhere when we're on a budget. Would we be prepared to reduce our first team budget for young kids?
In the spirit of the final Blackadder episode - Goooodbyeee!
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot] and 49 guests