Casforum • The Leading Castleford Tigers Community

jackknife wrote:Mata’utia
Clare
Minikin
Shenton
Eden
Trueman
Gale
Watts
Mcshane
Ikahihifo if true
Mcmeeken
Holmes
Millington

JSL
Moors
Clark
Milner

Would be mine although i stil think Roberts will start before Trueman

So Foster can't even get in the 17 ??????

westerbeast wrote:

jackknife wrote:Mata’utia
Clare
Minikin
Shenton
Eden
Trueman
Gale
Watts
Mcshane
Ikahihifo if true
Mcmeeken
Holmes
Millington

JSL
Moors
Clark
Milner

Would be mine although i stil think Roberts will start before Trueman

So Foster can't even get in the 17 ??????

No unfortunately i cant fit everyone in. Its only my opinion though n your welcome to have yours O:)

Would have to sacrifice Clare for Foster and put Minikin on the wing. Foster offers too much to not be in the side.

westerbeast wrote:Would have to sacrifice Clare for Foster and put Minikin on the wing. Foster offers too much to not be in the side.

Yep I agree. From a defensive point of view I would be much more confident of foster / minikin, than Clare / minikin. (And in attack too)

Clare was brought in as a back up winger, as he let us down when he as been picked I think not , he will get his chance as the season progresses, every club needs players like him when injury's start to bite

gateman wrote:Clare was brought in as a back up winger, as he let us down when he as been picked I think not , he will get his chance as the season progresses, every club needs players like him when injury's start to bite

Agreed Gateman. Clare fully deserves his place in the squad and provides solid back up, but he’s not a starting 17 player with everyone fully fit. Not in a side with silverware aspirations.

derbystiger wrote:

gateman wrote:Clare was brought in as a back up winger, as he let us down when he as been picked I think not , he will get his chance as the season progresses, every club needs players like him when injury's start to bite

Agreed Gateman. Clare fully deserves his place in the squad and provides solid back up, but he’s not a starting 17 player with everyone fully fit. Not in a side with silverware aspirations.

Totally agree and neither is Foster as a regular centre, does a good job in an emergency but we really do need better if we have any ambitions of silverware.

I think we all agree a top quality center is what we all want, if you read the posts from this time last year we were all making the same noises for a fullback and a prop, it took some time for the club to fill theses positions but in the end they got round to it, I have every faith in DP when the right one comes along he will go out and sign him its no good getting a player for the sake of it he as got to fit in

gateman wrote:I think we all agree a top quality center is what we all want, if you read the posts from this time last year we were all making the same noises for a fullback and a prop, it took some time for the club to fill theses positions but in the end they got round to it, I have every faith in DP when the right one comes along he will go out and sign him its no good getting a player for the sake of it he as got to fit in

Gateman agree with the majority thats first lol

I think a top quality winger would be just as valuable to us if we cant find any centres, replacing clare and leaving Minikin in centre.

I'm really leaning towards Foster in the centres for 2019. Since his debut, no one has give more to the team than he has. Looks like he's filling out a little bit too, maybe Powell has made his mind up.

heritage1926 wrote:I'm really leaning towards Foster in the centres for 2019. Since his debut, no one has give more to the team than he has. Looks like he's filling out a little bit too, maybe Powell has made his mind up.

sorry you have it wrong foster be loose forward all day long your right 100% effort every time but has no natural passing game which is essential how we play made a lot off bad passes last year when broke through typical direct forward bad enough with shentons passing ability

I believe that we took wardle as websters replacement but it seems he does not want to play there anymore am i the only one who thinks Roberts should go to right centre and leave minikin on the wing for another season

[quote="kippistiger"]I believe that we took wardle as websters replacement but it seems he does not want to play there anymore am i the only one who thinks Roberts should go to right centre and leave minikin on the wing for another season[/quot
we only need two back line injured in deflited line anyway and were snooked surely coaching staff now this well you would have thought they would but lets keep signing forwards on lol.

flow wrote:

kippistiger wrote:I believe that we took wardle as websters replacement but it seems he does not want to play there anymore am i the only one who thinks Roberts should go to right centre and leave minikin on the wing for another season[/quot
we only need two back line injured in deflited line anyway and were snooked surely coaching staff now this well you would have thought they would but lets keep signing forwards on lol.

Are you related to the copper from hello hello!

braytontiger wrote:

flow wrote:

kippistiger wrote:I believe that we took wardle as websters replacement but it seems he does not want to play there anymore am i the only one who thinks Roberts should go to right centre and leave minikin on the wing for another season[/quot
we only need two back line injured in deflited line anyway and were snooked surely coaching staff now this well you would have thought they would but lets keep signing forwards on lol.

Are you related to the copper from hello hello!

Was beginning to think it was just me!!!!

braytontiger wrote:

flow wrote:

kippistiger wrote:I believe that we took wardle as websters replacement but it seems he does not want to play there anymore am i the only one who thinks Roberts should go to right centre and leave minikin on the wing for another season[/quot
we only need two back line injured in deflited line anyway and were snooked surely coaching staff now this well you would have thought they would but lets keep signing forwards on lol.

Are you related to the copper from hello hello!

Very good Brayton. “Good moaning”