Page 3 of 4

Re: Hull FC v Castleford Tigers [CC Quarter Finals]

PostPosted: Sun Jun 18, 2017 3:37 pm
by nottinghamtiger
We've beaten ourselves here through ill-discipline. I thought most of the penalties we conceded were obvious penalties - stupid flops and unnecessary interference at the play of the ball.
We need t work on our own discipline.

Re: Hull FC v Castleford Tigers [CC Quarter Finals]

PostPosted: Sun Jun 18, 2017 3:42 pm
by TheSheriff
If you needed proof this game was rigged, that there is it. Clear tackle in the air but Hull get the ball.

Re: Hull FC v Castleford Tigers [CC Quarter Finals]

PostPosted: Sun Jun 18, 2017 3:47 pm
by InTheKnow
TheSheriff wrote:If you needed proof this game was rigged, that there is it. Clear tackle in the air but Hull get the ball.


Give over. We have been well beaten. Probably shouldn't even be this close.

Re: Hull FC v Castleford Tigers [CC Quarter Finals]

PostPosted: Sun Jun 18, 2017 3:48 pm
by chesterfieldtiger
I'm not one for usually slating referees. I did it for 10 years and know how hard it is but today Bentham has done his job perfectly. God knows how many penalties on last tackle and just to rub it in a blattant tackle in the aired child's gives a 20 restart. We will win nothing this year. The RFL Will make sure of that

Re: Hull FC v Castleford Tigers [CC Quarter Finals]

PostPosted: Sun Jun 18, 2017 3:49 pm
by TheSheriff
InTheKnow wrote:
TheSheriff wrote:If you needed proof this game was rigged, that there is it. Clear tackle in the air but Hull get the ball.


Give over. We have been well beaten. Probably shouldn't even be this close.


Bentham was man of the match, Cas never had a chance. Hull got away with murdered Cas got pinged for breathing near a Hull player.

Albert Kelly made more metres walking forward to play the ball than when he was actually carrying it!

Re: Hull FC v Castleford Tigers [CC Quarter Finals]

PostPosted: Sun Jun 18, 2017 3:49 pm
by smarty_tiger
It went the way most of us were nervous about, we were out - muscled.

Re: Hull FC v Castleford Tigers [CC Quarter Finals]

PostPosted: Sun Jun 18, 2017 3:51 pm
by TheSheriff
smarty_tiger wrote:It went the way most of us were nervous about, we were out - muscled.


No, they were out reffed. Hull were getting away with the same and worse.

If that game wasn't fixed then Bentham should be fired for gross incompetence because that is not how the game should be played.

Re: Hull FC v Castleford Tigers [CC Quarter Finals]

PostPosted: Sun Jun 18, 2017 3:52 pm
by old cas lass
InTheKnow wrote:
TheSheriff wrote:If you needed proof this game was rigged, that there is it. Clear tackle in the air but Hull get the ball.


Give over. We have been well beaten. Probably shouldn't even be this close.



Well beaten....8 points.
What would you call it if we lost by 20/30 points.
Would like to see the penalty count.

Re: Hull FC v Castleford Tigers [CC Quarter Finals]

PostPosted: Sun Jun 18, 2017 3:55 pm
by smarty_tiger
TheSheriff wrote:
smarty_tiger wrote:It went the way most of us were nervous about, we were out - muscled.


No, they were out reffed. Hull were getting away with the same and worse.

If that game wasn't fixed then Bentham should be fired for gross incompetence because that is not how the game should be played.

The ref did not get them their win. We were no where near as good as we have been.

Re: Hull FC v Castleford Tigers [CC Quarter Finals]

PostPosted: Sun Jun 18, 2017 3:55 pm
by chesterfieldtiger
So would I. Be astounded if it wasn't unbalanced

Re: Hull FC v Castleford Tigers [CC Quarter Finals]

PostPosted: Sun Jun 18, 2017 3:56 pm
by TheSheriff
smarty_tiger wrote:
TheSheriff wrote:
smarty_tiger wrote:It went the way most of us were nervous about, we were out - muscled.


No, they were out reffed. Hull were getting away with the same and worse.

If that game wasn't fixed then Bentham should be fired for gross incompetence because that is not how the game should be played.

The ref did not get them their win. We were no where near as good as we have been.


They won by 4 penalty goals and Cas had to defend a hell of a lot more because of one sided penalties. Bentham was a huge part of Hull winning that game.

Re: Hull FC v Castleford Tigers [CC Quarter Finals]

PostPosted: Sun Jun 18, 2017 3:59 pm
by smarty_tiger
TheSheriff wrote:
smarty_tiger wrote:
TheSheriff wrote:
smarty_tiger wrote:It went the way most of us were nervous about, we were out - muscled.


No, they were out reffed. Hull were getting away with the same and worse.

If that game wasn't fixed then Bentham should be fired for gross incompetence because that is not how the game should be played.

The ref did not get them their win. We were no where near as good as we have been.


They won by 4 penalty goals and Cas had to defend a hell of a lot more because of one sided penalties. Bentham was a huge part of Hull winning that game.

Your opinion and I respect that. Sounds like sour grapes Imo. There were some dodgy calls, no doubt, but Hull were the better controlled side and showed invaluable experience.

Re: Hull FC v Castleford Tigers [CC Quarter Finals]

PostPosted: Sun Jun 18, 2017 4:03 pm
by chesterfieldtiger
Not sour grapes at all. If we lose to a better team fair enough but we were on the back foot all game due to Bentham making sure we were. Amount of penalties on the last tackle was disgusting. And they were more guilty of laying on and moving g off the mark but never got penalised. As I said before. We will win nothing g the year. The RFL Will make sure of that

Re: Hull FC v Castleford Tigers [CC Quarter Finals]

PostPosted: Sun Jun 18, 2017 4:07 pm
by TheSheriff
I'd have no problem with being penalised if they penalised both teams equally but Bentham was only interested in pinging one team.

That's outright bias by the guy with the whistle, no 2 ways about it.

Re: Hull FC v Castleford Tigers [CC Quarter Finals]

PostPosted: Sun Jun 18, 2017 4:16 pm
by InTheKnow
old cas lass wrote:
InTheKnow wrote:
TheSheriff wrote:If you needed proof this game was rigged, that there is it. Clear tackle in the air but Hull get the ball.


Give over. We have been well beaten. Probably shouldn't even be this close.


Well beaten....8 points.
What would you call it if we lost by 20/30 points.
Would like to see the penalty count.


Yes well beaten. We had a good 20 minutes if that. Don't need to see the penalty count. We were holding on in the tackles allowing Bentham to think about giving penalties.

Our tackles were that poor Hull were back up on their feet ready to play the ball while our tackles were still on the floor most of the game.