Brayden Wiliame

[The Fox]

Was just looking at his suspension - one match ban for that late and high tackle on Connor, and then comparing it to the 3 match suspension that McShane got for quite an innocuous hit on Myler. Cannot work out how they can come up with these decisions at the RFL.

[Squaddie86]

Was just looking at his suspension - one match ban for that late and high tackle on Connor, and then comparing it to the 3 match suspension that McShane got for quite an innocuous hit on Myler. Cannot work out how they can come up with these decisions at the RFL.

Maybe because that "innocuous hit" was a deliberate elbow to the face?

I'm not saying the disciplinary panel isn't inconsistent, but people really need to understand that 3 games was a fair ban for a man who literally elbowed an opponent in the face and didn't get so much as a yellow.


Personally I'm more angry that Sam Powell only got 2 games, after his attempt to end Fifitas career.

[Fumper27]

Was just looking at his suspension - one match ban for that late and high tackle on Connor, and then comparing it to the 3 match suspension that McShane got for quite an innocuous hit on Myler. Cannot work out how they can come up with these decisions at the RFL.

Innocuous??? To quote the grate man himslef:

“Take off those rose tinted speccs you melt”

[takethetwo]

Was just looking at his suspension - one match ban for that late and high tackle on Connor, and then comparing it to the 3 match suspension that McShane got for quite an innocuous hit on Myler. Cannot work out how they can come up with these decisions at the RFL.

Maybe because that "innocuous hit" was a deliberate elbow to the face?

I'm not saying the disciplinary panel isn't inconsistent, but people really need to understand that 3 games was a fair ban for a man who literally elbowed an opponent in the face and didn't get so much as a yellow.


Personally I'm more angry that Sam Powell only got 2 games, after his attempt to end Fifitas career.

It was Jake Shorrocks with the hit to Fifitas knees, Powell got 2 games for seperate incident.

[jackknife]

Was just looking at his suspension - one match ban for that late and high tackle on Connor, and then comparing it to the 3 match suspension that McShane got for quite an innocuous hit on Myler. Cannot work out how they can come up with these decisions at the RFL.

Probky because the tackle was on Connor, i would have let Wiliame off with a warning and bought him a few pints

[scottiger]

Was just looking at his suspension - one match ban for that late and high tackle on Connor, and then comparing it to the 3 match suspension that McShane got for quite an innocuous hit on Myler. Cannot work out how they can come up with these decisions at the RFL.

The elbow was pretty bad let's be honest
Theres no vendetta against cas ffs.

[lurcher]

Was just looking at his suspension - one match ban for that late and high tackle on Connor, and then comparing it to the 3 match suspension that McShane got for quite an innocuous hit on Myler. Cannot work out how they can come up with these decisions at the RFL.

Probky because the tackle was on Connor, i would have let Wiliame off with a warning and bought him a few pints

i'd have given williams two points for the man of steel. connor is the ultimate grub.

[The Fox]

OK, OK - but before I "melt" away:

I never claimed anywhere that McShane's suspension was excessive, I compared his "offence" with the Wiliame "offence". Notwithstanding that the tackle was on Connor, in my opinion, Wiliame's tackle had the potential to inflict far more injury to the tackled player - he had both feet off the ground and hit Connor with his shoulder on his head, could easily have damaged his jaw, cheekbone or eye-socket. McShane's hit with the forearm was going to cause a bust lip or nose at the worst, and wasn't even seen by anyone until picked up by the cameras.

I don't have any issue with McShane getting 3 matches for it, but was merely pointing out that in comparison Wiliame has got off very lightly.

[flow]

OK, OK - but before I "melt" away:

I never claimed anywhere that McShane's suspension was excessive, I compared his "offence" with the Wiliame "offence". Notwithstanding that the tackle was on Connor, in my opinion, Wiliame's tackle had the potential to inflict far more injury to the tackled player - he had both feet off the ground and hit Connor with his shoulder on his head, could easily have damaged his jaw, cheekbone or eye-socket. McShane's hit with the forearm was going to cause a bust lip or nose at the worst, and wasn't even seen by anyone until picked up by the cameras.

I don't have any issue with McShane getting 3 matches for it, but was merely pointing out that in comparison Wiliame has got off very lightly.

don't worry about it just fumpers sense off humour. we all now like most things in rugby league were officials are involved it is in conistance ,just ask catalan fans last weeks try disaload lol.