Page 2 of 6

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 05 Dec 2018, 11:13
by Nobody
A lot of people think Foster will be there. I hope not his passing ability is not very good.

I think it will be Minikin or Roberts personally.

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 05 Dec 2018, 13:14
by gateman
IT looks almost certain that Minikin will start the season at centre that was the position he was brought in to play and that is were DP sees him, a FIT Benny Roberts would get into most teams lets hope he as more luck on the injury front as the poor lad seems to spend more time being unavailable than being available

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 05 Dec 2018, 14:43
by BigBez10
With the players that we know are missing for the first game I think we'll line up something like this:

Peanut
Clare
Minikin
Shenton
Eden
Trueman
Roberts
Watts
McShane
Millo
McMeeken
Foster
Milner

Massey
Jesse
Cook
Moors

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 06 Dec 2018, 15:26
by orrsome
gateman wrote:IT looks almost certain that Minikin will start the season at centre that was the position he was brought in to play and that is were DP sees him, a FIT Benny Roberts would get into most teams lets hope he as more luck on the injury front as the poor lad seems to spend more time being unavailable than being available
On Roberts, I’ve always thought that there is a very good player in there somewhere, but I have to say that he appears lazy sometimes. I just hope DP can re-ignite his enthusiasm back to 2017 levels for his final year with us. If he can remain fit and with the number of positions he can cover we could have a potential match winner off the bench.

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 07 Dec 2018, 13:21
by westyorkylad
Don't have an issue with BR filling in for Gale at all (despite the popular opinion I still rate him and think he's one of best attacking players) the only thing that does worry me is BR always seems to struggle with the heavy ground in the first 6 weeks or so of the season..................

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 07 Dec 2018, 13:48
by gateman
As you say Benny the good player he is struggle's on the heavy pitches, step up our pocket battleship Ellis

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 07 Dec 2018, 15:51
by Sharlotiger
BigBez10 wrote:With the players that we know are missing for the first game I think we'll line up something like this:

Peanut
Clare
Minikin
Shenton
Eden
Trueman
Roberts
Watts
McShane
Millo
McMeeken
Foster
Milner

Massey
Jesse
Cook
Moors
Agree with your starting 13 but not sure of the value of having 4 props on the bench when we are moving to only 8 interchanges.
I would have thought a back or utility player would have been a better option . Maybe swop Foster and JSL around.

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 10 Dec 2018, 14:18
by westyorkylad
gateman wrote:As you say Benny the good player he is struggle's on the heavy pitches, step up our pocket battleship Ellis
Its a good shout that Gateman, I think you've probably nailed it there, Truman and Ellis in the halves for the first 4 to 6 weeks is probably what we are going to see.......

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 10 Dec 2018, 14:38
by heritage1926
8 interchanges may actually work to our advantage over the season. Our pack is arguably the most mobile in the league, with pretty much every forward we have able to play 80 minute games. You look at the bigger packs in SL, Catalan, Saints, Hull etc and their big lads will struggle with more minutes.

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 10 Dec 2018, 15:08
by flow
Heard today the wardle swap deal as fallen through dont now if this is true or pub talk

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 10 Dec 2018, 15:17
by bane73
flow wrote:Heard today the wardle swap deal as fallen through dont now if this is true or pub talk
No surprise there then.

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 10 Dec 2018, 15:47
by gateman
i thought we had got a great signing when Wardle was announced , the lad as hardly reached any were near the form he showed at Huddersfield , he may have been carrying an injury I hope so , come on Joe show the form you are capable of

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 10 Dec 2018, 17:47
by Andrew6666
Sharlotiger wrote:
BigBez10 wrote:With the players that we know are missing for the first game I think we'll line up something like this:

Peanut
Clare
Minikin
Shenton
Eden
Trueman
Roberts
Watts
McShane
Millo
McMeeken
Foster
Milner

Massey
Jesse
Cook
Moors
Agree with your starting 13 but not sure of the value of having 4 props on the bench when we are moving to only 8 interchanges.
I would have thought a back or utility player would have been a better option . Maybe swop Foster and JSL around.
We need a winger if Minikin moves inside. Clare is a squad player not a starter.

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 10 Dec 2018, 22:02
by Fumper27
flow wrote:Heard today the wardle swap deal as fallen through dont now if this is true or pub talk
So you’ve actually added nothing to this debate with the above???

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 10 Dec 2018, 22:26
by flow
Fumper27 wrote:
flow wrote:Heard today the wardle swap deal as fallen through dont now if this is true or pub talk
So you’ve actually added nothing to this debate with the above???
his your purpose in life to be a bell end wants your point your trying to make I am asking a simple question as any body else heard same thing you just come on here to wide every body up your very brave sat behind your keyboard you keyboard warrior :-$ :-$ this is your only post on this topic is to criticise somebody else well done :clap: :clap: :clap:

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 10 Dec 2018, 22:38
by Fumper27
flow wrote:
Fumper27 wrote:
flow wrote:Heard today the wardle swap deal as fallen through dont now if this is true or pub talk
So you’ve actually added nothing to this debate with the above???
Is your purpose in life to be a bell end? What’s your point that you are trying to make? I am asking a simple question, has anybody else heard same thing? You just come on here to wind every body up. You are very brave, sat behind your keyboard, you keyboard warrior :-$ :-$ this is your only post on this topic, which is to criticise somebody else, well done :clap: :clap: :clap:
Just remind me where is the question in your original post? Also, topic is about the starting line up for 2019, not the rumoured swap deal between Cas and Huddersfield. No keyboard warrior, I just asked you a question which you have failed to even answer. Proves you never read the post and therefore, you have once again failed to add to this forum. Also, because it’s a quiet night, I have spell and grammatically checked and corrected your reply, just so the rest of the forum can read, digest and understand what (I think) you were trying to say. Please feel free to correct me if I am mistaken.

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 10 Dec 2018, 23:00
by flow
Fumper27 wrote:
flow wrote:
Fumper27 wrote:
flow wrote:Heard today the wardle swap deal as fallen through dont now if this is true or pub talk
So you’ve actually added nothing to this debate with the above???
Is your purpose in life to be a bell end? What’s your point that you are trying to make? I am asking a simple question, has anybody else heard same thing? You just come on here to wind every body up. You are very brave, sat behind your keyboard, you keyboard warrior :-$ :-$ this is your only post on this topic, which is to criticise somebody else, well done :clap: :clap: :clap:
Just remind me where is the question in your original post? Also, topic is about the starting line up for 2019, not the rumoured swap deal between Cas and Huddersfield. No keyboard warrior, I just asked you a question which you have failed to even answer. Proves you never read the post and therefore, you have once again failed to add to this forum. Also, because it’s a quiet night, I have spell and grammatically checked and corrected your reply, just so the rest of the forum can read, digest and understand what (I think) you were trying to say. Please feel free to correct me if I am mistaken.
a
what a boring man you are its a rugby forum not english lesson. the post means alot to the starting line up if wardle is staying like a said you have not added anything to the topic you just come on here to criticise people because you have nothing better to do go away little man.lmao love some people on here

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 11 Dec 2018, 00:06
by Fumper27
flow wrote:
Fumper27 wrote:
flow wrote:
Fumper27 wrote:
flow wrote:Heard today the wardle swap deal as fallen through dont now if this is true or pub talk
So you’ve actually added nothing to this debate with the above???
Is your purpose in life to be a bell end? What’s your point that you are trying to make? I am asking a simple question, has anybody else heard same thing? You just come on here to wind every body up. You are very brave, sat behind your keyboard, you keyboard warrior :-$ :-$ this is your only post on this topic, which is to criticise somebody else, well done :clap: :clap: :clap:
Just remind me where is the question in your original post? Also, topic is about the starting line up for 2019, not the rumoured swap deal between Cas and Huddersfield. No keyboard warrior, I just asked you a question which you have failed to even answer. Proves you never read the post and therefore, you have once again failed to add to this forum. Also, because it’s a quiet night, I have spell and grammatically checked and corrected your reply, just so the rest of the forum can read, digest and understand what (I think) you were trying to say. Please feel free to correct me if I am mistaken.
Its a rugby forum not english lesson.
Good job hey??? Anyway, back on topic. FWIW, as the current squad stands, Joe Wardle (IMHO) walks its our starting line up in the centre position vacantly by Jake Webster’s departure. This is where our esteemed coach earns his corn, by successfully managing the difficult members of the squad to get them on board with the rest of the group. In his time at Cas, I’ve not seen enough on Greg Minikin at centre that convinces me that he is the long term option. I hope he can prove me (and others) wrong but, at this minute, Wardle gets the centre berth for mine.

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 11 Dec 2018, 07:54
by Swagger
Fumper27 wrote:
flow wrote:
Fumper27 wrote:
flow wrote:Heard today the wardle swap deal as fallen through dont now if this is true or pub talk
So you’ve actually added nothing to this debate with the above???
Is your purpose in life to be a bell end? What’s your point that you are trying to make? I am asking a simple question, has anybody else heard same thing? You just come on here to wind every body up. You are very brave, sat behind your keyboard, you keyboard warrior :-$ :-$ this is your only post on this topic, which is to criticise somebody else, well done :clap: :clap: :clap:
Just remind me where is the question in your original post? Also, topic is about the starting line up for 2019, not the rumoured swap deal between Cas and Huddersfield. No keyboard warrior, I just asked you a question which you have failed to even answer. Proves you never read the post and therefore, you have once again failed to add to this forum. Also, because it’s a quiet night, I have spell and grammatically checked and corrected your reply, just so the rest of the forum can read, digest and understand what (I think) you were trying to say. Please feel free to correct me if I am mistaken.
People like you [REMOVED] me off. "I have grammatically checked and corrected your reply" get a grip of yourself. We all understood what he said so if anything you are the one to take this topic off point. People can't all spell properly or use correct grammer. But does it matter??? No. It's like being an online bully correcting people for making mistakes!!!

As for the topic....

I am happy where we are with our forwards but still feel unless we make a change to our backline we could be in for a tough season. They were caught out a few times last season and not sure how it gets any easier without a new, stronger player or two.

Re: Starting Line Up

Posted: 11 Dec 2018, 09:44
by cogito ergo sum
We don't know what Minikin will offer at centre unless he gets a prolonged spell there. Player grow into positions over time, and he was signed as a centre project.