Wingers For Next Year
Wingers For Next Year
With Hitchcox and Lo going/gone. Clare yet to sign his optional extension and hopefully Minikin seeing more time in the centres, who are our wingers for next season gonna be?
Eden is a certain
Gill for me will step up big time and into the top 3 at the club
Egodo seems like he needs another season on loan at a Championship club to help further his progress
I'd like to see Minikin bulk up over pre-season and given the opportunity to play in the centres
I'd pass on Clare's optional extension
Meaning we would need another wing man for 2019
Note: Egodo and Gill can/will both play in the centres too
Would Luke Briscoe or Adam Swift do the job for us?
I'd take Briscoe think he'd be class for us. Swift has the experience at an elite super league club and has electric pace but consistency is an issue.
Anyone else?
Eden is a certain
Gill for me will step up big time and into the top 3 at the club
Egodo seems like he needs another season on loan at a Championship club to help further his progress
I'd like to see Minikin bulk up over pre-season and given the opportunity to play in the centres
I'd pass on Clare's optional extension
Meaning we would need another wing man for 2019
Note: Egodo and Gill can/will both play in the centres too
Would Luke Briscoe or Adam Swift do the job for us?
I'd take Briscoe think he'd be class for us. Swift has the experience at an elite super league club and has electric pace but consistency is an issue.
Anyone else?
-
- League One Player
- Posts: 2191
- Joined: 08 Jul 2008, 00:20
- Location: On the brink
- Contact:
Re: Wingers For Next Year
Adam Swift :hand:
-
- Championship Player
- Posts: 5272
- Joined: 11 Jul 2006, 16:17
- Contact:
Re: Wingers For Next Year
Justin Carney?
- smarty_tiger
- Academy Player
- Posts: 1618
- Joined: 15 May 2009, 16:26
- Contact:
Re: Wingers For Next Year
I sincerely hope this is a joke thread if Swift is the contemplation for our new winger.
-
Verified
- Grand Final Winner
- Posts: 15893
- Joined: 31 Jan 2009, 03:55
- Contact:
Re: Wingers For Next Year
If we are signing Vaivai, he can play wing. I’d keep Clare as back up as he’s not likely to take up much cap space and is a reliable back up, a Cas lad and will always give 100%.
I’d then be tempted to bring in someone like Gelling for right centre.
Eden, Vaivai, Clare, Gill, Minikin
Shenton, Gelling, Minikin, Egodo + Webster if we want him for cover.
I’d then be tempted to bring in someone like Gelling for right centre.
Eden, Vaivai, Clare, Gill, Minikin
Shenton, Gelling, Minikin, Egodo + Webster if we want him for cover.
In the spirit of the final Blackadder episode - Goooodbyeee!
- smarty_tiger
- Academy Player
- Posts: 1618
- Joined: 15 May 2009, 16:26
- Contact:
Re: Wingers For Next Year
I agree that Clare is a very good back up option.HuddsTigers wrote:If we are signing Vaivai, he can play wing. I’d keep Clare as back up as he’s not likely to take up much cap space and is a reliable back up, a Cas lad and will always give 100%.
I’d then be tempted to bring in someone like Gelling for right centre.
Eden, Vaivai, Clare, Gill, Minikin
Shenton, Gelling, Minikin, Egodo + Webster if we want him for cover.
Re: Wingers For Next Year
It's a conversation about any winger in general that will benefit the club. Nobody said 'let's sign Adam Swift' I merely asked the forum users their opinion of him.smarty_tiger wrote:I sincerely hope this is a joke thread if Swift is the contemplation for our new winger.
- smarty_tiger
- Academy Player
- Posts: 1618
- Joined: 15 May 2009, 16:26
- Contact:
Re: Wingers For Next Year
That is completely fair and you have mine.MØL wrote:It's a conversation about any winger in general that will benefit the club. Nobody said 'let's sign Adam Swift' I merely asked the forum users their opinion of him.smarty_tiger wrote:I sincerely hope this is a joke thread if Swift is the contemplation for our new winger.
Re: Wingers For Next Year
FB and a centre are priority for 2019.MØL wrote:With Hitchcox and Lo going/gone. Clare yet to sign his optional extension and hopefully Minikin seeing more time in the centres, who are our wingers for next season gonna be?
Eden is a certain
Gill for me will step up big time and into the top 3 at the club
Egodo seems like he needs another season on loan at a Championship club to help further his progress
I'd like to see Minikin bulk up over pre-season and given the opportunity to play in the centres
I'd pass on Clare's optional extension
Meaning we would need another wing man for 2019
Note: Egodo and Gill can/will both play in the centres too
Would Luke Briscoe or Adam Swift do the job for us?
I'd take Briscoe think he'd be class for us. Swift has the experience at an elite super league club and has electric pace but consistency is an issue.
Anyone else?
Wingers we will have
Gill
Egodo
Minikin
Eden
Clare assuming we retain him
Shenton if were desperate
I would release maher and green and replace with 1 of better quality.
-
old cas lass Verified
- Grand Final Winner
- Posts: 23102
- Joined: 26 Dec 2007, 14:29
- Contact:
Re: Wingers For Next Year
Valentine Holmes.
Just a thought.
But wouldn’t it be nice.
Just a thought.
But wouldn’t it be nice.
-
- Championship Player
- Posts: 5272
- Joined: 11 Jul 2006, 16:17
- Contact:
Re: Wingers For Next Year
The players I think would be best would cost us a fee, but might be tempted to move.
RW - Vai Vai.
RC - Mata’utia
LC - Shenton
LW - Eden
I do rate Mikinin and he’d be my first choice to play if any of these four were out or covering a different position.
RW - Vai Vai.
RC - Mata’utia
LC - Shenton
LW - Eden
I do rate Mikinin and he’d be my first choice to play if any of these four were out or covering a different position.
Re: Wingers For Next Year
eden yes but got to think bigger then clare egodo gill letting jy go who s better then all three need class winger to sign to challenge for top trophy's will go backwards if use filling in playersfords wrote:FB and a centre are priority for 2019.MØL wrote:With Hitchcox and Lo going/gone. Clare yet to sign his optional extension and hopefully Minikin seeing more time in the centres, who are our wingers for next season gonna be?
Eden is a certain
Gill for me will step up big time and into the top 3 at the club
Egodo seems like he needs another season on loan at a Championship club to help further his progress
I'd like to see Minikin bulk up over pre-season and given the opportunity to play in the centres
I'd pass on Clare's optional extension
Meaning we would need another wing man for 2019
Note: Egodo and Gill can/will both play in the centres too
Would Luke Briscoe or Adam Swift do the job for us?
I'd take Briscoe think he'd be class for us. Swift has the experience at an elite super league club and has electric pace but consistency is an issue.
Anyone else?
Wingers we will have
Gill
Egodo
Minikin
Eden
Clare assuming we retain him
Shenton if were desperate
I would release maher and green and replace with 1 of better quality.
Re: Wingers For Next Year
'filling in players' have to start somewhere..
-
- Championship Player
- Posts: 5272
- Joined: 11 Jul 2006, 16:17
- Contact:
Re: Wingers For Next Year
The problem is that Jy takes up a quota spot that prevents us from signing someone who would improve the starting 17. If he wasn’t on the quota I think we’d be resigning him.flow wrote:eden yes but got to think bigger then clare egodo gill letting jy go who s better then all three need class winger to sign to challenge for top trophy's will go backwards if use filling in playersfords wrote:FB and a centre are priority for 2019.MØL wrote:With Hitchcox and Lo going/gone. Clare yet to sign his optional extension and hopefully Minikin seeing more time in the centres, who are our wingers for next season gonna be?
Eden is a certain
Gill for me will step up big time and into the top 3 at the club
Egodo seems like he needs another season on loan at a Championship club to help further his progress
I'd like to see Minikin bulk up over pre-season and given the opportunity to play in the centres
I'd pass on Clare's optional extension
Meaning we would need another wing man for 2019
Note: Egodo and Gill can/will both play in the centres too
Would Luke Briscoe or Adam Swift do the job for us?
I'd take Briscoe think he'd be class for us. Swift has the experience at an elite super league club and has electric pace but consistency is an issue.
Anyone else?
Wingers we will have
Gill
Egodo
Minikin
Eden
Clare assuming we retain him
Shenton if were desperate
I would release maher and green and replace with 1 of better quality.
Re: Wingers For Next Year
true but have to sign better then clare egodo would give gill a chance on is hull kr game but need a class winger don't just want to attack just down one wing .
-
- Championship Player
- Posts: 5272
- Joined: 11 Jul 2006, 16:17
- Contact:
Re: Wingers For Next Year
We do have Minikin though and in a salary-capped sport we can’t have top-line players (earning top-line money) as back-ups.flow wrote:true but have to sign better then clare egodo would give gill a chance on is hull kr game but need a class winger don't just want to attack just down one wing .
I’d be happy (ish) with Eden, Minikin, Clare and Gill.
In an ideal world we’d sign a top winger and Minikin could cover across the back line, but with the salary cap we have in place strengthening one area inevitabely means we can’t strengthen another.
Re: Wingers For Next Year
glad your not running the club mate we would be average mid table club with eden injury prone you would go with clare and gill we have surplus forwards which can be offloaded to pay for a decent winger ](*,)nottinghamtiger wrote:We do have Minikin though and in a salary-capped sport we can’t have top-line players (earning top-line money) as back-ups.flow wrote:true but have to sign better then clare egodo would give gill a chance on is hull kr game but need a class winger don't just want to attack just down one wing .
I’d be happy (ish) with Eden, Minikin, Clare and Gill.
In an ideal world we’d sign a top winger and Minikin could cover across the back line, but with the salary cap we have in place strengthening one area inevitabely means we can’t strengthen another.
-
- Championship Player
- Posts: 5272
- Joined: 11 Jul 2006, 16:17
- Contact:
Re: Wingers For Next Year
No, if Eden is injured I’d go with Minikin and one of Clare/Gill.flow wrote:glad your not running the club mate we would be average mid table club with eden injury prone you would go with clare and gill we have surplus forwards which can be offloaded to pay for a decent winger ](*,)nottinghamtiger wrote:We do have Minikin though and in a salary-capped sport we can’t have top-line players (earning top-line money) as back-ups.flow wrote:true but have to sign better then clare egodo would give gill a chance on is hull kr game but need a class winger don't just want to attack just down one wing .
I’d be happy (ish) with Eden, Minikin, Clare and Gill.
In an ideal world we’d sign a top winger and Minikin could cover across the back line, but with the salary cap we have in place strengthening one area inevitabely means we can’t strengthen another.
As I say, I don’t disagree that in an ideal world we’d sign a top winger to play with Eden. But ultimately a SL squad is always a compromise as the salary cap prevents any team from having top players in every position and as back-ups. In my view, paying more for a top full-back will make more difference than spending money on a winger.
It’s the reality of a salary-capped sport. This isn’t Championship Manager and you can’t have everything.
Re: Wingers For Next Year
I think we need a big powerful winger and centre combo to play on right with shenton n eden to keep doing what they do on the left.
Like Webster and Carney but a younger version
Like Webster and Carney but a younger version
CLASSY CAS FOREVER
-
- Championship Player
- Posts: 5272
- Joined: 11 Jul 2006, 16:17
- Contact:
Re: Wingers For Next Year
Mata’utia and Vai Vai would be superb.jackknife wrote:I think we need a big powerful winger and centre combo to play on right with shenton n eden to keep doing what they do on the left.
Like Webster and Carney but a younger version
If Leigh don’t get promoted, I can’t see Mata’utia staying there.
Alternatively, given Salford’s money problems, I’d be happy to take Junior Sa’u as a replacement for Webster.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Ahrefs [Bot], Bing [Bot] and 61 guests