I would. His decision making is terrible. Shot out of the line far too many times today, one he dropped and they scored from. He needs to concentrate on his rugby, he's not a captain for me.MØL wrote:You'd get rid of Shenton!heritage1926 wrote:We need 2 new centres for 2019. Webster to retire and Shenny is absolute stop trying get round the swear filter and read the AUP
what on earth happened?
-
- League One Player
- Posts: 3597
- Joined: 10 Jan 2018, 15:27
- Contact:
Re: what on earth happened?
Re: what on earth happened?
Anyone saying get rid of shenton legitimately don't know what they're talking about.
Re: what on earth happened?
Loosing 4 forwards is never going to make things easy.
Neither is not having your starting 1/6/7/9 on the pitch to start.
I think If we could have brought say millo or watts on in that 2nd half it would have made a big difference.
My.only concern is we have all been thinking 'we can hit the super 8s hard with players back'. But we seem to be loosing people quicker than getting them back. And you have to wonder if we are rushing them back too, Webster looked miles off the pace, and mcshane should have really been tested.
Neither is not having your starting 1/6/7/9 on the pitch to start.
I think If we could have brought say millo or watts on in that 2nd half it would have made a big difference.
My.only concern is we have all been thinking 'we can hit the super 8s hard with players back'. But we seem to be loosing people quicker than getting them back. And you have to wonder if we are rushing them back too, Webster looked miles off the pace, and mcshane should have really been tested.
Re: what on earth happened?
Think some have drunken to much of the sauce at the game today. Poor team performance today so yes let's sack our world class England international captain.Towns88 wrote:Anyone saying get rid of shenton legitimately don't know what they're talking about.
Re: what on earth happened?
Its always same on here when we loss ive said mesen there were some poor performances today but no need to rip into players....or draw i should have added
The measure of who we are is what we do with what we have
Vince Lombardi
Vince Lombardi
Re: what on earth happened?
Was also some positives. For me thought Moors had a cracker and Jesse too before he went off. Jy finished well and didn't put a foot wrong. Minikin although not amazing (as with the bulk of the team) played better than the Warrington game (still likely playing banged up).tigerfeat wrote:Its always same on here when we loss ive said mesen there were some poor performances today but no need to rip into players
Re: what on earth happened?
Just asking, who would your two centres for 2019 be?heritage1926 wrote:I would. His decision making is terrible. Shot out of the line far too many times today, one he dropped and they scored from. He needs to concentrate on his rugby, he's not a captain for me.MØL wrote:You'd get rid of Shenton!heritage1926 wrote:We need 2 new centres for 2019. Webster to retire and Shenny is absolute stop trying get round the swear filter and read the AUP
-
- Academy Player
- Posts: 1413
- Joined: 17 Sep 2016, 10:17
- Contact:
Re: what on earth happened?
Isn’t Bateman the England CentreMØL wrote:Think some have drunken to much of the sauce at the game today. Poor team performance today so yes let's sack our world class England international captain.Towns88 wrote:Anyone saying get rid of shenton legitimately don't know what they're talking about.
Re: what on earth happened?
Might be Connor come next weekend.takethetwo wrote:Isn’t Bateman the England CentreMØL wrote:Think some have drunken to much of the sauce at the game today. Poor team performance today so yes let's sack our world class England international captain.Towns88 wrote:Anyone saying get rid of shenton legitimately don't know what they're talking about.
Re: what on earth happened?
Greg Minikin is a concern for me. He doesn't seem fit. So why isn't gill involved ?
Re: what on earth happened?
Yeah. Hate to see him playing injured especially when Gill is more than capable of stepping in.Towns88 wrote:Greg Minikin is a concern for me. He doesn't seem fit. So why isn't gill involved ?
Re: what on earth happened?
The whole right hand side Minikin.Webster and Qlt was shocking. Hkr cut them open with a butter knife every timeTowns88 wrote:Greg Minikin is a concern for me. He doesn't seem fit. So why isn't gill involved ?
Re: what on earth happened?
Id be after the lad that was at centre for them now he does look a good player
The measure of who we are is what we do with what we have
Vince Lombardi
Vince Lombardi
-
- Academy Player
- Posts: 1676
- Joined: 20 Jun 2016, 08:47
- Contact:
Re: what on earth happened?
Don't agree. Admittedly first try was a bit easy. Second try, a fluke, third try a big lad forcing his way over, fourth try a last tackle kick when we were gassed.Dez wrote:The whole right hand side Minikin.Webster and Qlt was shocking. Hkr cut them open with a butter knife every timeTowns88 wrote:Greg Minikin is a concern for me. He doesn't seem fit. So why isn't gill involved ?
We've had better days, but scored 5 to 4. No panic. I actually thought Minikin had a good game.
Re: what on earth happened?
He def played better than the Warrington game. Foster for me has to be our right centre for the reminder of 2018.cogito ergo sum wrote:Don't agree. Admittedly first try was a bit easy. Second try, a fluke, third try a big lad forcing his way over, fourth try a last tackle kick when we were gassed.Dez wrote:The whole right hand side Minikin.Webster and Qlt was shocking. Hkr cut them open with a butter knife every timeTowns88 wrote:Greg Minikin is a concern for me. He doesn't seem fit. So why isn't gill involved ?
We've had better days, but scored 5 to 4. No panic. I actually thought Minikin had a good game.
-
- Academy Player
- Posts: 322
- Joined: 26 Feb 2018, 17:07
- Contact:
Re: what on earth happened?
Yes foster does palMØL wrote:He def played better than the Warrington game. Foster for me has to be our right centre for the reminder of 2018.cogito ergo sum wrote:Don't agree. Admittedly first try was a bit easy. Second try, a fluke, third try a big lad forcing his way over, fourth try a last tackle kick when we were gassed.Dez wrote:The whole right hand side Minikin.Webster and Qlt was shocking. Hkr cut them open with a butter knife every timeTowns88 wrote:Greg Minikin is a concern for me. He doesn't seem fit. So why isn't gill involved ?
We've had better days, but scored 5 to 4. No panic. I actually thought Minikin had a good game.
Re: what on earth happened?
Patton would of been nice. Any chance of persuading Mitchell Moses to come over.........the machine wrote:We need another halfback to partner gale for 2019heritage1926 wrote:We need 2 new centres for 2019. Webster to retire and Shenny is absolute dogshiz
-
Verified
- Grand Final Winner
- Posts: 15893
- Joined: 31 Jan 2009, 03:55
- Contact:
Re: what on earth happened?
When you have Moors having to play something like 55 minutes you have problems. Thought we killed them in opening quarter but the tide turned when they brought on Lunt. They did well to slow the ruck down and killed any momentum we had. Thought Vaivai was excellent and their best player. Seen some people questioning attitude and effort but for me that wasn’t lacking at all. The boys did everything they could to get us over the line but were just outdone by a fresher team towards the end. Shame because with a fully fit rotated bench I reckon we would have won comfortably.
Would have won with conversions.
We beat Warrington who we didn’t think we would so in essence we have surpassed our expectations of only having 2 pts/4. Silver linings and all that.
Onwards to Wigan which now is a bigger game given we are an extra point behind them.
Would have won with conversions.
We beat Warrington who we didn’t think we would so in essence we have surpassed our expectations of only having 2 pts/4. Silver linings and all that.
Onwards to Wigan which now is a bigger game given we are an extra point behind them.
In the spirit of the final Blackadder episode - Goooodbyeee!
Re: what on earth happened?
Looks as though he was limping since he went Down with about 25 mins left and then saw him leave in a moon boot with crutches.cogito ergo sum wrote:Don't agree. Admittedly first try was a bit easy. Second try, a fluke, third try a big lad forcing his way over, fourth try a last tackle kick when we were gassed.Dez wrote:The whole right hand side Minikin.Webster and Qlt was shocking. Hkr cut them open with a butter knife every timeTowns88 wrote:Greg Minikin is a concern for me. He doesn't seem fit. So why isn't gill involved ?
We've had better days, but scored 5 to 4. No panic. I actually thought Minikin had a good game.
Thought everyone put effort in today, might have been a disappointing result but still got a point and in 4th spot with a game in hand and if we win will take us to third.
Re: what on earth happened?
HuddsTigers wrote:When you have Moors having to play something like 55 minutes you have problems. Thought we killed them in opening quarter but the tide turned when they brought on Lunt. They did well to slow the ruck down and killed any momentum we had. Thought Vaivai was excellent and their best player. Seen some people questioning attitude and effort but for me that wasn’t lacking at all. The boys did everything they could to get us over the line but were just outdone by a fresher team towards the end. Shame because with a fully fit rotated bench I reckon we would have won comfortably.
Would have won with conversions.
We beat Warrington who we didn’t think we would so in essence we have surpassed our expectations of only having 2 pts/4. Silver linings and all that.
Onwards to Wigan which now is a bigger game given we are an extra point behind them.
I agree. I didn't leave questioning our attitude today. Also when you have a young and inexperienced spine , it won't always go well. Not to mention we were in their half once in the last 10 mins.
Thought moors had a really strong game which was pleasing.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot], Google [Bot] and 64 guests